How to Help Patients Get a Single Case Agreement for Out-of-Network Mental Health Care
Navigating insurance barriers can be a challenging task for mental health providers and patients alike. In this week’s podcast episode, we delved into the nuances of single case agreements (SCAs) and how they empower patients to receive necessary care from out-of-network providers. SCAs, though complex, are often a viable solution for patients in need of specific services that may not be readily accessible within their insurance network. This blog post explores what SCAs are, when they’re commonly used, and practical strategies for both patients and providers to negotiate and secure these agreements.
Image: Unsplash
What is a Single Case Agreement in Mental Health, and When is it Most Commonly Used?
A single case agreement (SCA) is a contractual arrangement between a healthcare provider and an insurance company that allows a patient to access out-of-network care while still receiving in-network benefits. Typically, SCAs are used in cases where the required services are not readily available within the insurance company’s network. This might include higher levels of care, such as intensive outpatient programs (IOP), partial hospitalization programs (PHP), or residential treatment.
However, SCAs are also increasingly relevant for outpatient mental health services, particularly for in-person therapy. With many insurance providers prioritizing telehealth, SCAs are often a critical solution for patients who need in-person care and can’t find suitable in-network options.
Image: Unsplash
How to Make the Case for a Single Case Agreement in Outpatient Mental Health Care
Even if in-network providers are available, there are often valid reasons to pursue a single case agreement in outpatient settings. The most compelling arguments focus on the specific needs of the patient that in-network providers may not meet. Here are some key points to consider:
1. Availability and Accessibility
Many in-network providers may lack availability, aren’t taking new patients, or can’t offer the type of care the patient requires. Showing that multiple in-network options were explored but weren’t viable strengthens the case.
2. In-Person Care Requirement
Telehealth can be beneficial, but some patients—particularly younger ones—thrive with in-person interaction. Highlighting this need can make a strong argument for an SCA.
3. Specialized Needs
Patients may require a provider with specific expertise or demographic preferences, such as a particular gender or background, or someone who can offer both therapy and medication management.
4. Continuity of Care
If the patient has an established relationship with an out-of-network provider, continuity of care can be crucial. Switching providers may disrupt treatment, potentially impacting the patient’s progress.
Image: Unsplash
Educating Patients on the Single Case Agreement Process for Better Access to Care
Asking for a single case agreement can be intimidating for patients, so it’s essential to approach this conversation in a way that empowers and informs them. Here’s how providers can guide patients through the process:
1. Explain the Benefits
Start by clarifying that an SCA could make the patient’s care more accessible by applying in-network benefits to an out-of-network provider.
2. Clarify the Patient’s Role
Let patients know that their advocacy is essential, as insurance companies are often more responsive to direct requests from patients. Providers can assist, but the patient needs to make the initial calls.
3. Empower with Talking Points
Offer key points to discuss with the insurer, such as a lack of suitable in-network options or the need for in-person care. Some providers offer handouts that include these points and relevant state laws to bolster the patient’s case.
4. Set Realistic Expectations
Help patients understand that the SCA process involves both authorization and rate negotiation. Getting the authorization doesn’t guarantee final approval, as terms still need to be agreed upon.
5. Offer Reassurance and Support
Encourage patients to reach out for support and be persistent. Some providers even help by calling the insurance company if needed or recommending the patient ask for a case manager to streamline communication.
Image: Unsplash
Step-by-Step Process: How to Request a Single Case Agreement
The SCA request process involves several formal steps, with providers offering guidance along the way. Here’s a breakdown:
1. Patient Initiates Contact
Patients begin by calling their insurance company and requesting an SCA, explaining the need to see an out-of-network provider due to limited in-network options.
2. Justify the Request
Patients should outline the specific factors that make the SCA necessary. Providers can prep patients on the best points to emphasize, such as the need for specialized care or in-person services.
3. Advocate for Timely Care
In many states, patients have rights to timely mental health care. If in-network providers can’t meet these timelines, an SCA may be more likely to get approved.
4. Provider Follow-Up as Needed
While patients initiate the request, providers can follow up to provide additional details, making a case for why the patient’s needs aren’t met by in-network options.
5. Authorization and Negotiation
Once approved, the provider negotiates the reimbursement rates, ideally aiming for compensation close to their standard rates.
6. Handling Denials
If the request is denied, providers can encourage patients to file a complaint with the state insurance board to potentially prompt reconsideration.
Image: Unsplash
Negotiating Rates for Single Case Agreements: A Guide for Providers
Once an SCA is authorized, providers enter the negotiation phase with the insurance company. Here’s a typical approach to negotiating rates:
1. Set Expectations
Inform patients upfront that while authorization is granted, final rates are yet to be negotiated.
2. Begin with Standard Rates
Providers should quote their regular rates, emphasizing that SCAs require additional work and, as such, merit fair compensation.
3. Limit Discounts
Unlike in-network agreements, SCAs are more flexible. Providers are advised to minimize discounts, if any, to around 10-20%.
4. Leverage Established Rates
Providers with previous SCAs with the same insurer can reference those established rates to negotiate favorable terms for new agreements.
5. Escalate if Necessary
If there’s resistance, providers may need to escalate by questioning discrepancies in rate offers, sometimes framing it as potential unfair treatment.
6. Document the Agreement
Once terms are agreed upon, ensure all details are documented, including authorized sessions, specific rates, and expiration dates.
Image: Unsplash
How Long Do Single Case Agreements Last? Understanding Duration and Renewal
SCAs are generally temporary arrangements, often lasting up to a year, though they can vary. Here’s what providers should know:
1. Authorization Periods
Many SCAs last for a defined period, often up to a year, or until the end of the calendar year.
2. Session Limits
Insurance companies frequently set caps on sessions, requiring providers to specify billing codes and reimbursement rates for each.
3. Renewal Process
When the authorization period or session limit is near, the patient or provider must contact the insurer to renew.
4. Provider Responsibility
Providers should track expiration dates and session limits, using reminders within electronic health records to prompt renewal when necessary.
Image: Unsplash
Mental Health Business Moment of the Week
In this week’s business moment, a recent network negotiation with an insurance company highlighted the challenges providers face with reimbursement rates. After establishing a promising in-network relationship with one insurer, a mental health provider was encouraged to apply with a partnered insurance company, expecting similar reimbursement terms.
However, upon receiving the rates, the provider discovered that the new insurer’s rates were significantly lower—approximately 40% of the initial company’s rates, resembling outdated compensation levels. This discrepancy raised questions about the viability of such agreements and the need for systemic changes, perhaps through legislation, to standardize fair reimbursement rates across insurers.
Using Single Case Agreements to Improve Mental Health Care Access
Single case agreements can be powerful tools for patients and providers, allowing greater flexibility and access to needed care. However, the SCA process involves several steps and a commitment to patient advocacy, negotiation, and persistence. By understanding and utilizing SCAs effectively, mental health providers can help patients access specialized care that may not be available within their insurance networks, creating positive outcomes for both patients and practices.
Stay tuned for more insight and stories in next week’s blog post!
Looking for a health record solution that simplifies your workflows and supports your practice’s business needs?
RipsyTech has your back. Schedule a demo with us today.
